St. Clement's by-the-Sea in the News

Friday, October 17, 2003

Orange County Register

Anglicans won't split now
But leaders warn of church division if U.S. branch consecrates gay bishop.

 
SECURITY: Police stand guard Thursday outside London’s Lambeth Palace, where Anglican church leaders were meeting.
JOHN D. MCHUGH, THE ASSOCIATED PRESS


Knight Ridder Newspapers

 

LONDON – Anglican church leaders said Thursday that they had avoided for the moment a fatal rupture in their worldwide alliance after two days of crisis talks, but warned the U.S. Episcopal Church that consecrating a gay bishop could still provoke a split.

In a four-page statement issued Wednesday night, the 37 primates, as leaders of the autonomous "provinces" that make up the 70 million-member Anglican Communion are known, said they had "a firm desire" to remain united but acknowledged they had deep divisions over homosexuality.

They singled out a recent decision by their American branch to elect a gay man, the Rev. Canon V. Gene Robinson, as bishop of New Hampshire, and a Canadian church's blessing of a same-sex union for jeopardizing their unity. They predicted possibly grave consequences if Robinson's consecration, scheduled for Nov. 2, goes ahead.

"If his consecration proceeds, we recognize that we have reached a crucial and critical point in the life of the Anglican Communion and we have had to conclude that the future of the Communion itself will be put in jeopardy," the statement said.

VOICES
• "This is an opportunity for change and growth. We can either secede in fear or we can trust in Jesus that he will make things right in the end. ... (Conservative parishes) have my pastoral care and nurture. ... They will understand that their conscience will not be violated and I will not force them into anything they don't want to do."
JOHN BRUNO, bishop of the Diocese of Los Angeles


• "I applaud the fact that they want all voices to stay together. ... I think that's the thing that makes us as Anglicans strong - that we do have these multiple voices that can come together and talk."
REV. DIANE BRUCE, rector of St. Clement's by the Sea Church in San Clemente


• "On the one hand, (Anglican leaders) are sincerely, prayerfully struggling to uphold the communion, but at the same time not sacrificing the truth we believe. We're trying to follow the historic teaching of the church and Scripture. This is not to condemn anyone. We believe all of us equally stand before God. ... (If Episcopalians consecrate a gay bishop), our people here at St. James are so devastated as it is, it will be like cutting them to pieces."
REV. PRAVEEN BUNYAN, rector of St. James Church in Newport Beac
h

"In this case, the ministry of this one bishop will not be recognized by most of the Anglican world, and many provinces are likely to consider themselves to be out of Communion with the Episcopal Church," the statement said.

Robinson declined to be interviewed Thursday but last week indicated through a spokesman that he had no plans to bow out. A statement issued by the Diocese of New Hampshire on Thursday night said it regretted that other Anglicans were grieving over its election of Robinson but it "looked forward" to his consecration Nov. 2.

"Canon Robinson was elected based on his nearly three decades of ministry in the diocese, his considerable pastoral skills, and his vision for ministry," the statement also said. "His sexuality was incidental to his call to serve as our bishop."

Louie Crew, a gay activist and member of the Episcopal Church's Executive Council from Newark, N.J., who was in London to lobby on Robinson's behalf, said that he doubted the cleric would back off or delay his consecration.

"Absolutely not," Crew said. "That would send the wrong signal."

The Episcopal Church's Presiding Bishop, the Most Rev. Frank T. Griswold, who participated in the two-day meeting at Lambeth Palace, defended the decisions of the Diocese of New Hampshire and the Episcopal Church's General Convention as proper. When asked during a news conference if he would pressure Robinson to step aside, he said that attending Robinson's consecration was on his calendar but coyly emphasized that events could change his plans.

"Any number of things can happen," Griswold said. "The second coming could occur, which would certainly cancel the whole thing."

The primates urged Archbishop of Canterbury Rowan Williams, who is the symbolic head of the Anglican Communion but lacks authority to intervene in the affairs of Anglican churches outside England, to establish a commission to consider extending his role under exceptional circumstances that threaten the wider body. They asked the commission to complete its work within 12 months, by which time Robinson may have already become a bishop.

Williams described the emergency meeting, which he called after African bishops and conservative Anglicans in the West strongly objected to Robinson's election, as "very remarkable" and characterized it as painful, honest and open.

"It has certainly not been easy," he said. "It's quite clear from our discussions that issues around homosexuality are difficult and divisive. These issues will continue to cause pain and anger, misunderstanding and resentment all around."

Conservatives who had hoped the primates would punish the Episcopal Church by severing links between it and other Anglican branches were disappointed that the statement did not go further.

"I wish it would have been stronger," said the Rev. Canon David Anderson, president of the conservative American Anglican Council, 3,000 of whose members protested Robinson's election at a meeting in Dallas last week. "I would have liked to see more teeth in it."